Grading of Trails


Went on the "1200 steps trail" at air itam with Sifu, Kenny, Raymond, Susumu San and a group of bikepushers blogspot cyclsts. It was a good ride and good mtb lesson for me from Sifu esp this is my 3rd trail ride. The gradient was steeper than what I expected. Hv to stop a few times to reach the top, a mere 4 miserable Km taking almost an hour !!! Before going up the trail my impression was a tougher trail esp after my last last to the Hokkien Cemetery at BAtu Gantong.

Wud it make sense for someone who is well versed with the trails like Turbosnail and gang to come up with some grading system as a guide to newbies like me and outsiders visiting Penang who wanted to do some trails riding. I noticed a lot name given to trails eg Ngor Hean, Firefly trail, Sacred Heart, Iron cross etc etc.

To set the ball rolling, i wud grade for the 7 trails I hv been (correct me if I am not so accurate )  ; 1   to   5  ("1" easiest  .  "5" severest)

1)  HERITAGE RIDE              1   ( flat unchallenging terrain for all age groups)

2) PEARL HILL                     2    (Strenuous but manageable for reasonable fit cyclists)

3) MT ERSKINE                    2   (Strenuous but manageable watch out for hazards)

4) TLK BAHANG                   2    (Manageable, watch out for road traffic at Ferringhi)

5) 1200 STEPS                    3    (Strenuous, above average to cycle up all the way)

6) GERTAK SANGGUL           3    (Strenuous and challenging esp the slope down certain part)

7) ROUND ISLAND               4    (Challenging)

8) BATU GANTONG CEMETRY   5     (Very strenuous, for seasoned cyclists)

Please refer to this link for grading of trails www.forestry.gov.uk/forestry/infd-6mrmeu

 

 

 

Share/Save

look368 - Posted on 01 January 2010

Since Daniel has started working on the trails again, I feel it appropriate to bring this thread in again. So everyone, hopefully, we can all contribute to the grading of new trails

For No. 1, don't la put 'for kids'. Make me malu if I want to do Heritage Ride. Embarassed

Hi Diana,

Good to see u blogging again. Ok I hv chg it to all age groups. See both of you soon.

Hahaha! Thanks Doc! Cool

Diana, has Mike fixed his BIONIC legs ???

Cheers

Captain, not yet. He's seeing the specialist on Monday.

Wah!! Daniel has done up the different color coding for the diff level of trails so beautifully. lets hope all of us will grade our ride / trail after each ride. I believe Daniel will create a new icon for trails and grades soon

Dear Dr,

It is a great idea and helps a lot for new riders who are always very keen to

attend new trail, however it is still not sure if it is suitable for them  or not.

From this point of view, I am agreeable for 101 % of this idea, and hope

this will be shown at any trail introduced from now on.

 

I know it is not easy to show it with exact figure however, any description would

be helpful to let them decide if they are qualified to attend or not.

" Better than nothing",and at least it was described by person who really attended,it is

very valuable indication, I believe. 

Perhapy the way of description are to be amended from time to time, however

this will be the first step to go forward for the year of 2010.

Many thanks again,Dr for your new trial of this idea,and it is very much appreciated

from new riders point of view.

Susumu

       

 

I was informed by Dr that Bikepushers have added a link in their blogspot site to ours and therefore in accordance to our reciporal link policy we now add a link to their site. Check menu option Link.

I laughed my pants off when I read their comments on the photos they posted. A funny blog it is!

yeah lah so many TOLAK one!!!!

MTB = Mari Tolak Basikal

or during past years Penang Jamboree = 'Merry Tolak Basikal'

That is a good one. No one they all tolak basikal all the way

I thought that MTB = Mari Terbang/Terjun Basikal ...hahah

Dr,

I browsed the net for grading trail difficulties and I found that these terms are commonly used  : EASY, MODERATE and CHALLENGING.  In between there are EASY TO MODERATE, MODERATE TO CHALLENGING.

Can I suggest that instead of just saying that a 'trail is graded 2', which does not really tell a lot, can we describe a ride as '2 MODERATE ?  So redoing your grading above, I have this-

Trail Grade Description
HERITAGE RIDE 1 EASY; A piece of cake  -  flat unchallenging terrain for kids
PEARL HILL 2 EASY TO MODERATE; Strenuous but manageable for reasonable fit cyclists
MT ERSKINE 2 EASY TO MODERATE; Strenuous but manageable watch out for hazards
1200 STEPS 3 MODERATE;Strenuous, above average to cycle up all the way
ROUND ISLAND 4 MODERATELY CHALLENGING; for reasonably fit cyclists
BATU GANTONG CEMETRY 5 CHALLENGING; Very strenuous, for seasoned cyclists only

Grading trails are quite subjective.  But if we can consistently apply the grades to all our trails, it can be a useful guideline for cyclists...my 2 sens

Mountain biking trail grades

<!-- THE MAIN PAGE CONTENT -->


Trail grades are split between those for cross-country singletrack trails and those for bike parks and forest roads.

This is to highlight that:

  • forest roads can be of variable difficulty and are not part of a progression on to green and blue level singletrack trails.
  • Similarly, orange-graded bike parks are not simply a progression on from singletrack grades.
  • Explanations for each of the gradings are given below the symbol tables.

Cross country singletrack trail grades

Grade Symbol
Green - easy A green circle means an easy grade trail
Blue - moderate A blue square means an moderate grade trail
Red - difficult A red triangle means a difficult grade trail
Black - severe A black diamond means a severe grade trail

These are a general indication of difficulty - there are easier and more tricky options available within each grade.

Non-singletrack trail grades

Grade Symbol

Orange Bike Park

An orange lozenge means an extreme grade for a bike park
Forest road and similar Routes may or may not be waymarked

The grades explained:

Cross country singletrack trail grades

Green grade - easy trails

  • Green grade trails are suitable for: beginners or novice cyclists.
  • Bike required: most bikes and mountain bike hybrids are suitable.
  • Skills needed: basic bike skills are required for this grade.
  • Trail and surface types: these will be relatively flat and wide. Trail surface might be loose, uneven or muddy at times. Might include short flowing singletrack-style sections. Some green routes can take trailers.
  • Gradients and technical trail features: climbs and descents are mostly shallow. No challenging features.
  • Suggested fitness level: suitable for most people in good health.

Blue grade - intermediate trails

  • Blue grade trails are suitable for: intermediate cyclists or mountain bikers with basic off-road riding skills.
  • Bike required: basic mountain bike or mountain bike hybrid.
  • Skills needed: basic off-road riding skills to cope with uneven surfaces and small obstacles.
  • Trail and surface types: as for 'green', plus specially constructed singletrack trails. Trail surface might include small obstacles of root and rock.
  • Gradients and technical trail features: most gradients are moderate but might include short steep sections. Includes small technical trail features (such as roots and rock).
  • Suggested fitness level: a good standard of fitness can help.

Red grade - difficult trails

  • Red grade trails are suitable for: proficient mountain bikers with good off-roading skills.
  • Bike required: quality off-road mountain bikes.
  • Skills needed: good off-roading skills and techniques to cope with technical trail features.
  • Trail and surface types: steeper and tougher, mostly singletrack with technical sections. Expect very variable surface types.
  • Gradients or technical trail features: a wide range of climbs and descents of a challenging nature will be present. Expect boardwalks, berms, large rocks, medium steps, drop-offs, cambers and water crossings.
  • Suggested fitness level: a higher level of fitness and stamina is required.

Black grade - severe trails

  • Black grade trails are suitable for: expert mountain bike users, used to physically demanding routes.
  • Bike required: a good quality off-road mountain bike is needed.
  • Skills needed: advanced level off-roading skills and technical ability.
  • Trail and surface types: as for 'red', but with an expectation of greater challenge and continuous difficulty. Can include any useable trail and might include exposed open hill sections.
  • Gradients or technical trail features: expect large, committing and unavoidable technical trail features. Sections will be challenging and variable. Might also have 'downhill' style sections.
  • Suggested fitness level: suitable for very active people used to prolonged effort.

Non-singletrack trail grades

Orange - bike park

  • Bike parks are suitable for: riders aspiring to an elite level of technical ability; incorporates everything from full on downhill riding to 'big air' jumps.
  • Trail and surface types: severe constructed trails and/or natural features. All sections will be challenging. Includes extreme levels of exposure or risk. Jumping ability obligatory.
  • Gradients or technical trail features: will include a range of small, medium and large technical trail features, including downhill trails, freeride sections and mandatory jumps.
  • Suggested fitness level: a good standard of fitness is recommended but technical skills are more important.

Forest road and similar

  • Forest roads are suitable for: a wide range of cyclists. 
  • Bike required: most bikes and mountain bike hybrids are suitable
  • Skills needed: basic map reading will be helpful for roads which are not waymarked or signposted
  • Trail and surface types: relatively flat and wide. The trail surface might be loose, uneven or muddy at times. These roads might be also be used by vehicles and others including horse riders and dog walkers.
  • Gradients and technical trail features: gradients can be very variable and might include short, steep sections. Occasional potholes might be present. Routes might not be waymarked or signposted.
  • Suggested fitness level: a good standard of fitness can help.

Warning signMountain biking is a potentially hazardous activity carrying a significant risk. It should only be undertaken with a full understanding of all inherent risks. These guidelines must always be used in conjunction with the exercise of your own experience, intuition and careful judgment.

I find round island very tough especially scalling the teluk bahang hill.  Batu Gantong hill is steep but the distance is shorter and overall the ride is easier except certain parts need to carry the bike.  My personal opinion after riding batu gantong once and round island twice.

ok, point taken. Daniel had upgraded the round island to level 4. I am probably biased in the batu gantong trail because of my tumble!!

Thanks for the comment. Hope more of you will contribute to the trail grading.

 

Recent comments

Recent Forum

Recent blogs

News & Stories

Gclub Members

dshee-Daniel Shee
chicken-Johnathan
turbosnail-
look368-Lim SG
Sorento G-
Mycle-Ooi Soo Beng
thiswei-Cheong Chong wei
Captain-Ronnie Tan
robertlee-Robert Lee
Ong868-
engcheong-
farmer-Gerald Foo
mcfleong-Micheal Leong
msteh-Teh MS
ahloon88-
raymond-
takeuchi-Takeuchi Minoru
LeeYong-Lee Yong
deswynwan-
jay-
ginefly-Fang Ling
skywalker-Kek WK
KNTXX-
dleepg-David Lee
akkhor-
kenny-Yeoh Keat Siew
wayne-Mel Looi
Diana-
Ng Zeng Ping-
Fudge-
Charmain Ang-
Mohammad Safwan Lim Bin...
Wong Shyang Tatt-Wong Shyang...
lawrence hanoman-lawrence lim...
Broken Chain-GT Yeoh
Quah Beng Guan-Quah BG
Tan Kim Leong-
Aung Moe-Alex
Timothy Wooi-Timothy Wooi
chandotcom-
Fairoz Zakaria-
fab01-
stingray-Raymond Tan
mincc76-
bryan886-
nightrider-Jason Choong
kenyueneoh-
eskay yeoh-
9W2LPP-
otsin62-Ooi Teik SIn
Black snail-Poh Tat
tonyanita-Anthony Gill
limbh-
tayglim-
pcchin-
saifini81-Mohd Saiful Bahril...
ken.swoo-Ken Soon
brumic-
susumutomiyama-
waionn-
chrislai75-
helpdesk-See Hui
wusolow-
wankeong-
alprider-Andreas Grassmann
seng chiang-Lim Seng Chiang
Poh Lee-Teh Poh Lee
Jeffrey lim-
adrenning-Ning Seong Leong
adhraz-
syntax79-Steven Yap
Daniel Lee-Daniel Lee
sptan007-Edwin Tan
Brandon-Brandon Ong
thomas-Ngo Thye Aun
museeuwbikes-Nik
blominator-Barend Blom
jwbiker-jack wong
eweliang-Ch'ng Ewe Liang
gordon.chan-Chan Hwa Kai
Frankie-Frankie Tan
kevin-Kevin Chan Kah Fai
jie-jie
Peanut-Nelson
wade-phuah ming yang
tykwang-YK
leongfeihong-darren khoo
calven-Gnooi kok fong
darkstar747-JAYASENA JAMES
Mohd Jasni-Mohd Jasni Bin...
GELim-Lim Gim Eng
kongtuck-Cheong Kong Tuck
ah wei-ah wei
EC Rider-RK
Sam Koay-Sam Koay
andy lee-andy lee
maraza-maraza
tunhawkmtb-tun ahmad sukri
kleinbike-jonathan
David-David Chan
uncle lee-Khor Kheng Lee
adchin-Adrian Chin
andy_tans-Andy
michael oh-michael oh
markg-Mark
blindedbyman-Joe Lim
fchinx-Chin Weng Yew
choonhwa-goh choon hwa
beng bin-beng bin
bromptonsingapore-Steven Lim
beehong-Tan Bee Hong
GE KHOO-KHOO GIM ENG
FattYan-FattYan
Sarina Mat Desa-Sarina Mat...
r1flyguy-Gary
hlim12-Lim Hoe Hock
yl chong-FRANCIS CHONG
yskeong-SK Yeong
CarismaGT-Dennis Tan
weychyuan-Bernard Lim Wey...
Geong-Ng GC
rueben67-Rueben Arunasalam
ghtan929-Tan Guan Hin
krishnan-Sara Krishnan
wai-TUNG WAI CHOON
clchong84-Chong Cheong Look
danny_tkw-Tan Kok Wai
looiwk-Marcus Looi
Esmond-Tan Keh Heng
Nancy Lee-Lee Nianci
Sam Liaw-Sam CM Liaw
Christy S-Christy Schrader
sunnyleow-Sunny Leow Lai Huat
leelaifu-Lee Lai Hock
bhlim-lim beng hock
SlowRider-Rouven Patrick Tan
kwangye-kelvin lim
CHUNG FOOK CHEEN-Chung Fook...
khoobt1-KHOO BOO TEONG
ironhorse-Patrick Tan Teik...
eohvince-Vincent Eoh
sjghouse-syedjaafarghouse
unitedislife-Andrew Chee
danielchoo-Daniel Choo
KELVIN THARM-Cupido Kelvin
sean61-Wee Chong siang
Tatsuya Fujita-Tatsuya Fujita
maychow-May Chow
Konadawg-Quah Hock Chye
VOLKS5925-Muhammad Haniff...
rasdi95-Muhamad Rasdi Bin Abd...
alexctooi-Ooi
slooi91-Ooi Soo Liang
Abracadabra-Raymond Tan
jimmyleow-Jimmy Leow
kellymay-Kelly Koay
BMCcabuk-hasnol
dharma-dharma...
matlon-zamani
foldingbike-Well Tan
lilmomo0220- Eric Teoh
seehwan-David Ang
dR MTB-Azmil Bin Jamil
Gary Yeap-Yeap Gim Hong
darren1333-chuah KL
htkoay5065-Koay Hean Tatt
teohenghooi-Teoh Eng Hooi
Eric Yong-Eric Yong
kctham-KC Tham
qayrul-khyroL
httan-Albert Tan
Jeffrey Kot-Jeffrey Kot
ken5-ken fai
shamsul saaedin-shamsul...
Soon-Aun-Yeoh Soon Aun
ahtong-li chao dong
pohhengbicycle-LIM POH HENG
mic6326-tan chun hau
MichaelGerdEhlert-Ehlert
bro_sardono-Sardono bin...
cktan101-Chor Keong Tan
didihisa89-Adilah
tsling75-Teh TH
johnkoh-John Koh
LUN-NG QIU LUN
leeweeleong-lee wee leong
Samantha Hor-Samantha Hor
wendylawhk-LAW HAR KHENG
Tang Kiang Heng-Tang Kiang...
pyanghani-Mohd Suffian
northsitechiff-faizul
Rizal-Harizal Bin Abu Hassan
adnanbinmustafa-Adnan bin...
keong109-Lim Gim Keong
hahnyee-yee wai hon
kelvin-Kelvin Loh
apelf-Clement
samlaw-Sam Law
Zainal74-Zainal Abd Jalil
plkvoon-Lim Kian Voon
jemay-Mohd Azman Bin Ibrahim
Freeze-Aidi Karsi
patyeegclub-Patrick Yee
mzba73-mohdzahir ahmad
mo.ca7-Seow Jiunn Chang
fizzi79-Mohd Afizi Bin Mat...
neizaramli-Rosniza Ramli
dcong-ong duu chee
Jasonng-Jason Ng Chee Seong
WillyWee-Willy Wee
Nicholas23z-Nicholas Ng Chuan...
empty.7-Seow Jiunn Chang
terrenceteh_27-Terrence Teh
hckoay-Koay Hean Chong
ayie-shuhairi ibrahim
krajah-rajah s/o krishnan
popi-mohd hafifi bin mohd...
billyli3-Billy Lim
hgyeoh-Yeoh Hong Guan
GhaniSyam-Abdul Ghani Zainol
wandaniyal-Wan Daniyal bin...
zack-Mohamed Zainulalawdin...
engchye-Loh Eng Chye
leemingyeang-LEE MING YEANG
karhin-Khoo Kar Hin
albert82-Wong Soo Keong
elicaong-Elica Ong
calck81-KHOO CHEE KEONG
Mei Ling-Mei Ling
ronjrl-Lim Chin Keat Gerad
penang_foldie-Colin Lamb
inaslursa-Asrul Sani Abdullah
Jamell Chiru-
xianlim-
Louisa-Louisa
wilsonsoon1983-Wilson Soon
Lucasloh86-Lucas Loh
lpmtbclub-Bernard Lim
Andrew NG-Andrew NG
hassan abdul hamid-Hassan bin...
dickson yeap-dickson yeap
sim6163-sim tze thong
asriearmy77-Zairil Asri...
SELINAOH-OH BEE HWA
yvan79-Chian Sin Ye
ksoon-Keith Soon
shen-Shen Set Ho
nabil-nabil fikri
WatlaoA-Sew Kok Leong
gulfy07-yeoh kean haaw
mcmschng-chng gs
LeanChee-Khoo Lean Chee
hstan87-Terrance Tan
siewm-siewmei
pseeyap-Yap Phaik See
cutiesboyzz-Marcus Tan Han...
BT Lim-B T Lim
chiang7-Lim Chin Chiang
PhilexHoo-HOO SOON PENG
CA Tang-Tang Chin Aun
khoo eng theng-Khoo Eng Theng
daneychou-CHOU CHIN HWA
cheah chen soo-cheah chen soo
Ziv ching-Ching Xin Yuen
Happy89-LIM KHAI XIN
chuahbl-Chuah Bee Ling
rocky chin-chin whai pang
zackchew-Isaac Chew
toh sheau han-toh
Jia Xin Ng-Ng Kar Hin
Yang Khoo-khoo teng yang
cttan-Tan chor teik
hoe-khanghoe
waterbull-Tan Teik Huat
cheongwai-Hoong Cheong Wai
LiLian-LiLian
Partyanimal-Sebastian Toh
jqronnii65-RONNIE QUAH
randeron-Adrian Ooi
huannchin-Lim Huann Chin
cheahlit-Lim Cheah Lit
WilliamHoe-HOE CHIN KHWAN
feikoon-Koay Fei Koon
wsleong12-Leong Wee Seong
Supateri Merida-Noor Supateri...
Sueyin-Sueyin Lee
hazritrek-Hazriharun Ooi bin...
Yeapcola-Yeap Chuen Hoong
James59-Law Kim Aik
oem711-Ong Ee May
Nling Ng-Ng Huey Ling
minyi-LOH MIN YI
Ceylene Lee-LEE CHOOI YONG
maylin-Maylin
yusri MTB-yusri bin md yusoff
Joven.GOH-Joven Goh Chern Yi
Jonathan Tan-Tan Siew Hung
kpleow-Leow Kok Ping
Tacvis Loo Leong Hong-Tacvis...
Muhammad Sabri-Muhammad Sabri...
kidkvn-kevin yee
twoichek@yahoo.com-Tang Woi...
ROSLAN BIN MOHAMED-ROSLAN BIN...
k2exotech-Jaron
bbnoobs-james loh heng zhi
boonpeen84-Tan Boon Peen
kkloh-Loh Keong Kong
sam1628-Sam Tan
boonhooi-KHOO BOON HOOI
SELENA CHOONG-SELENA CHOONG
ricklee-Rick Lee
HK Lim-Lim Hong Kwan
chunhow-Lee Chun How
Nothingsman-Tan Woei Yit
limhoui-lim chin wooi
TJ koid-TJ
Shallynn Teoh-Shallynn Teoh
angel7-Angela Loh
arnibrahim-ARINI BT MOHD...
wan_haniff-wan haniff bin...
Leo Khaw-Leo

Who's online

There are currently 0 users and 6 guests online.

Who's new

  • lee542
  • belanda
  • Dolphine
  • leasha1014
  • Leo Khaw